featuring the very best of americana, alt.country and roots music
July 1, 2026
Scott Foley, purveyor of dust
There was a time when the Avett Brothers were volatile. Their home-brewed, approximate harmonies and walloped instruments were fresh and exciting, albeit this side of amateurish. Brothers Seth and Scott and third wheel Bob Crawford wore that lack of polish as a badge on their off-the-rails raves as well as their hyper-earnest ballads. The formula worked to garner the Avetts a staunch live following, and eventually a deal with a larger label and a world-class producer.
This brings us up to 2009 and their Rick Rubin-produced I and Love and You. We followed the Avett Brothers onto The Carpenter and Magpie and the Dandelion and even into True Sadness, though their mainstream popularity and increasing polish tempered our enthusiasm. There's absolutely nothing wrong with artistic maturity, and domestic stability is something we'd wish on any worthy performer. As we've expressed on a regular basis, that early rough garage electricity is simply impossible to maintain as we become more seasoned performers.
Heck, we'll even forgive the Avetts their ill-fated Broadway musical. Their left-field collaboration with Mike Patton (AVTT/PTTN) served to remind us that Seth and Scott remain open to novelty like we like, even if we didn't strongly represent the project here at R&B HQ. Returning to Four Thieves and Emotionalism in compiling our Lookback list rekindled some of that early enthusiasm and jogged our memory of some of the brothers' genuinely good stuff. We didn't include anything from their four live packages, but recommend them as documents of their fabled stage show.
AVETT BROTHERS: thirty favorites
- "Pretty Girl From Matthews" Country Was (2002)
- "November Blue"
- "Traveling Song" A Carolina Jubilee (2003)
- "At the Beach" Mignonette (2004)
- "Swept Away"
- "Salvation Song"
- "Talk On Indolence" Four Thieves Gone - the Robbinsville Sessions (2006)
- "Colorshow"
- "Dancing Daze"
- "When I Drink" The Gleam EP (2006)
- "Die Die Die" Emotionalism (2007)
- "Paranoia In B Major"
- "Weight Of Lies"
- "Ballad Of Love and Hate"
- "I Would Be Sad"
- "Murder In the City" Second Gleam EP (2008)
- "I and Love and You" I and Love and You (2009)
- "Head Full Of Doubt/Road Full Of Promise"
- "Kick Drum Heart"
- "Laundry Room"
- "Live and Die" The Carpenter (2012)
- "February Seven"
- "Open Ended Life" Magpie and the Dandelion (2013)
- "No Hard Feelings" True Sadness (2016)
- "True Sadness"
- "I Wish I Was"
- "Tell the Truth" Closer Than Together (2019)
- "Victory" Third Gleam EP (2020)
- "Love Of a Girl" Avett Brothers (2024)
- "Eternal Love" AVTT/PTTN (2025)
--------------------------
To enjoy any Spotify ROUTES-cast, just open Spotify and search for "routesandbranches" to access this most recent playlist, as well as many others from past months. Or click here for a preview:





