featuring the very best of americana, alt.country and roots music
June 30, 2026
Scott Foley, purveyor of dust
Fact is, this week we had something nearly complete in praise of River Shook's debut solo record, something we'll still strongly recommend. But we've also been spending time with an artist who has shared a stage with Shook recently, Andrew Sa. Each time we returned American Rough to the turntable our appreciation grew, until this morning we decided to fully cast our lot with Sa rather than Shook.
This is where that IF YOU ONLY LiSTEN to ONE RECORD THiS WEEK becomes problematic. On a week when we're also looking at new projects from American Aquarium and Keenan O'Meara (not to mention Beth Orton), we fully suggest you listen to MORE THAN ONE RECORD ...
American Rough is co-produced with HC McEntire and Missy Thangs, working with Andrew Sa to walk a line between novelty throwback and genuine original. With a voice that has been compared to Roy Orbison and Raul Malo, the challenge is to conjure an arrangement that doesn't cloak Sa's songs in nostalgia. Fact is, songs like "Follow" and "Lavender Cowboy" are perfectly beautiful. The former boasts an immediately familiar snare pattern with lovely strings, while the latter even directly sites "Angel Band" even as it draws an alluring picture of queer attraction. In these more trad settings, Sa's voice shines like a more polished Jimmie Dale Gilmore.
The album's songs are best honored, however, and Sa's possible future is most readily visible, as sounds and sonic ideas are folded into the mix. The reedy sax on "Your Whisper" suggests a jazz ballad sensibility, joined by swarming strings adding just a touch of mystery. Written with Liam Kazar, "Under You" layers harmony vocals as pedal steel echoes from wall to wall: Let me stay a nickel in your fountain.
Where Orville Peck is brawny, Andrew Sa brings a bruised spirit to his music and delivery. "Gorgeous Things" blooms with terrific arrangement choices, from woozy violin to low-tuned electric guitar: You've got a pair of little brown eyes / Hanging on you tonight. American Rough can't help but be hopelessly romantic, it's just in the Chicago songwriter's nature: On every chiseled face out there / I picture your facial hair. Cue the horn section, this side of vampy.
River Shook's self-titled record succeeds in acknowledging what we already know. In Andrew Sa, however, we revel in the spirit of music discovery. An acknowledged fan of artists like Rufus Wainwright and kd lang (in addition to Patsy Cline, natch), Sa's future might see him wisely expand his music reach beyond the baseline he establishes on American Rough. On "Where It Lands", with collaborators McEntire and Rosali, Sa delivers the project's most promising passage. Sounding not unlike ANOHNI in a tamer moment, the singer croons atop a digital murmur: The eye can wander forever / Isn't love where it lands.
--------------------------





